.jpg)
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled
Wednesday in favor of the state of Texas, upholding its ban on in-person ballot
collection when financial compensation is involved. With this decision, the
court overturned a lower court's injunction that had blocked the law's
implementation, allowing it to take effect immediately.
In an opinion written by Justice Edith H. Jones and
supported by a unanimous three-judge panel, the Supreme Court determined that
Texas Senate Bill 1—passed in 2021—is not ambiguous enough to render it
unconstitutional or violate First Amendment rights. According to the court, the
bill provides sufficiently clear guidelines for citizens to understand which
actions are prohibited.
Furthermore, the ruling held that the lower court
overstepped its bounds by issuing injunctions against state officials,
contravening the principles of sovereign immunity that protect states from
certain legal actions. Thus, the decision reaffirms the state's ability to
implement its electoral policies while legal and political debates continue
regarding their impact on the democratic process.